General News

Advocate Phoolka defends Kuldip Nayar – advises Sikhs to close the book controversy

July 22, 2012 | By Sikh Siyasat Bureau

New Delhi, India (July 22, 2012): As per media reports senior Sikh advocate H. S. Phoolka has asked the Sikh organizations to stop protests against veteran journalist Kuldip Nayar for his book Beyond The Lines; An Autobiography while accepting his apology in the spirit of remembering and appreciating his past endeavours for the community.

“Recalling several instances where Nayar took up cudgels against the union government in eighties not only as a journalist but also as an activist to seek justice for the Sikhs, Phoolka, face of legal battle for getting justice for the victims of November ’84 Sikh massacres, said that it was unfortunate that a controversy started regarding his recent book and he was being projected by some organizations as if Nayar was an enemy of the Sikhs” reports Times of India (TOI).

“Though I also may not agree with Nayar on some of the things mentioned in his book, but that does not mean that we should forget and wash away all the contribution he has made in the past to the Sikh community and start projecting him as the enemy of the Sikhs,” Advocate Phoolka is quoted to have argued by TOI.

Nayar has already tendered an Apology to appease any sections of the community that may have felt hurt, Advocate Phoolka said while adding, that apology should have finished the matter especially when he had promised to remove a few portions from his book in future editions.

“It must not be lost sight of that many of the things written by Nayar in his book have been written by many other authors in books published earlier, but they were not challenged or brought up with such furore nor was an apology ever offered,” he pointed out.

Kuldip Nayar’s name was among the few well known Journalists at the National level who fully supported the Sikhs during those difficult days of eighties. “His contribution is not only as a journalist, but as an activist as well. I have been a part of many movements which have been led by Nayar on issues relating to Sikhs. Some of these are as follows,” he said.

He recalled Nayar’s leading role in forming Emergency Virdhi Morcha in Punjab in 1987, courting arrest for getting Jodhpur detainees released in 1988, Constitution of Nanavati Commission after Nayar raised the issue in Rajya Sabha in 1999, spearheading a campaign after Nanawati’s report after which government ultimately had to succumb to pressure and agreed to register the cases against Tytler and Sajjan Kumar and Tytler had to also resign from the Union Cabinet as a Minister. It was Nayar’s petition in Delhi High Court which led to appointment of a special public prosecutor to handle the cases of Nov’84 Genocide, H. S. Pholka recalled.

“In view of the contribution of Nayar and his role in the past many decades, it is in the interest of the Sikhs and in the spirit of appreciating what all Nayar has done in the past that the apology should be accepted and further protests should be stopped,” he added.

Tweet

---

To Get Sikh Siyasat News Alerts via WhatsApp:

(1) Save Our WhatsApp Number 0091-855-606-7689 to your phone contacts; and
(2) Send us Your Name via WhatsApp. Click Here to Send WhatsApp Message Now.

Sikh Siyasat is on Telegram Now. Subscribe to our Telegram Channel

---

Related Topics: Advocate Harvinder Singh Phoolka, Beyond the Lines - an autobiography, Kuldip Nayar

Leave a Reply